Same situation but different scenarios for week 17. A week ago, the Philadelphia Eagles needed the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to lose to the San Diego Chargers in order to control their own destiny in the NFC playoff race, but the Eagles failed to live up to their end of the bargain, losing on the road to the Washington Redskins. This past Sunday, losses by either the Minnesota Vikings or the Chicago Bears (or even both of them) and then another loss by Tampa Bay would allow the Eagles another shot to get in. And when the Bears lost to the Houston Texans and the Buccaneers dropped their fourth straight game to the woeful Oakland Raiders, it made the Eagles and Dallas Cowboys game a “Win and Get In” situation.
And the Eagles didn’t ask for control…they took it away with force.
After an opening first quarter with the score at 3-3, the score was never close once after that point, as the Eagles posted 24 points in the second quarter and 17 in the third quarter on their way to a through 44-6 dismantling of the Cowboys, avenging a loss in week two on Monday Night Football in Irving. The funny thing is that the two touchdowns the team did score in the second half came from their defense with two fumble recoveries out of a total five forced turnovers.
At the end of the day, the Eagles qualified for the playoffs, entering in at the #6 spot with a 9-6-1 record and will face a team that the Eagles should know very well, that being Brad Childress and the NFC North champion Minnesota Vikings. The day and time for that match will be determined by Tuesday, from what we do know is that if the Eagles are going to do it, they are going to have to replicate the Pittsburgh Steelers of 2005 or the New York Giants of 2007 and win them all on the road.
Quarterbacks: Wow, I think someone needs to thumb through the record books for this season, because I can’t remember the last time Donovan McNabb had as few pass attempts as he did. Sure, McNabb had some scrambles and sneaks, but the defense was a big reason for that with their two touchdowns in the 3rd quarter. McNabb completed 12 of 21 passes (57%) for 175 yards and two touchdowns through the air, posting a 116.2 QB rating. And on the ground, McNabb scrambled three times for four yards, including a 1-yard touchdown keep to give us the lead, once and for all. And even on the sideline, there seemed to be no problems as expressed by the “Media” between him and anyone else. Later on, Kevin Kolb made the scene and, luckily, was not implored to throw the ball, but he did get on the board with two kneel downs to end the game.
McNabb Grade: A (95%)
Running Backs & Full Backs: There were a total 23 carries between our top two runners, Brian Westbrook and Correll Buckhalter, but it was the latter who got less carries but did more with his attempts. In fact, Buckhalter was the versatile one this game, not Westbrook, as Buckhalter jammed for 63 yards on ten carries, including a run good for 33-yards because apparently the “Great” Dallas defense must have been taking tackling lessons from Cleveland and Denver. Buckhalter also caught three passes for 59 yards and a touchdown from four yards out, totaling 122 yards on 13 touches (9.4 yards per) and a touchdown. Westbrook had 13 carries for 50 yards and two receptions for 12 yards, totaling 15 touches for 62 yards and a VERY questionable fumble. Kyle Eckel posted eight carries for 22 yards rushing, most of which came in the fourth quarter.
Unit Grade: A (95%)
Wide Receivers: Due to the lack of pass attempts, and on top of that the running backs hauling in five of the 12 receptions, passes were hard to come by for these guys. In fact, it was so hard that only three guys here caught a pass, as DeSean Jackson, who had four drops a week ago in Landover, had two receptions for 46 yards, including 34-yards on a nice inside route. Reggie Brown and Kevin Curtis, the latter of whom missed the Redskins game, both had one reception.
Unit Grade: B (83%)
Tight End: Yeah, notice the “S” is missing off of that one, because we only had one tight end making a statement, and no, it wasn’t the overpaid LJ Smith because apparently he was “injured.” Brent Celek co-led the team with three receptions for 30 yards, including a 1-yard touchdown reception with 13 seconds to the half. Also, it should be made mention of that Matt Schobel was in the game, but if anyone saw him anywhere, please feel free to tell me.
Unit Grade: B+ (89%)
Offensive Line: Back in week two, the Eagles offensive line allowed five sacks to the Cowboys, and there must have been at least a dozen more times where McNabb had to fight off pressure in order to avoid taking another sack. But this time, Dallas managed only one sack and one quarterback hurry, both from Bradie James, and sack artist DeMarcus Ware, who came into the game with 20 of them, left with zero. The line allowed the actual runners on the team 4.3 yards a carry (we won’t include the two quarterbacks) and committed no fouls (although Philadelphia committed NONE as a team). For the season, the line, which has again seen three starting right guards, going from Shawn Andrews to Max Jean-Gilles to Nick Cole, allowed only 23 sacks on Kevin and Donovan. That is five less then they did in 2006 and a very sharp decrease of 26 from last year.
Unit Grade: A+ (98%)
Defensive Line: One would have to be quick to forgive Tony Romo, because if he felt as if he was stuck in some never ending horror movie where he kept getting sliced and diced instead of sacked and pressured, then it would be understandable. Despite missing Victor Abiamiri due to what I would assume was some sort of injury, seven of the linemen still enjoyed the mayhem they created, starting with Darren Howard who had three tackles, a sack, a tackle for a loss, a QB hurry, and one pass defense. Juqua Parker also had three tackles along with a pass defense, and Chris Clemons had easily his best game as an Eagle, posting two solo tackles, two sacks, two QB hurries, a tackle for a loss, a forced fumble, and a recovered fumble from Brian Dawkins off of Romo which he took for a touchdown. Both starting tackles Broderick Bunkley and Mike Patterson had two total tackles (one solo and one assist) and backup tackle Trevor Laws recovered his first fumble of the season, the one that Clemons forced. Trent Cole didn’t get a tackle but was always entering the backfield and had one pass defense. In all, the line piled up three sacks, three QB hurries, and helped to hold Dallas to 87 yards rushing on 19 carries. Of course, the actual runners of Marion Barber and Tashard Choice averaged 4.3 yards a run.
Unit Grade: A (95%)
Linebackers: Jason Witten, who has traditionally killed the Eagles, made seven catches again but was held to only 50 yards, thanks in large part to Akeem Jordan. Jordan, who had five more tackles then the rest of the linebackers put together and four more then Dallas’s leading tackler (James had seven), Jordan had 11 tackles for the game, including two of them for a loss. Both Chris Gocong and Stewart Bradley pitched in two tackles and Bradley had a “pass defense” right in front of Witten which was a dropped interception. Also making an appearance at linebacker was Omar Gaither, who lost his job at WILL to Jordan back before the Ravens game, had a tackle for a loss, and Tracey White had one tackle.
Unit Grade: A- (90%)
Secondary: If Brian Dawkins is not back in midnight green again in 2009, it better be for a DAMN good reason, like he chooses to retire, and not because we can’t re-sign him. In traditional rise up and take charge fashion, the crazy man who leads the fans in our fight song chant after scores from the sideline had five tackles, two forced fumbles, a sack, a tackle for a loss, and a QB hurry. Quintin Mikell had four tackles and two pass defenses, and was in prime position for another interception, much like he was in Landover, but failed to get it. Quintin Demps pitched in two tackles after Dawkins left the game in the third quarter, and Joselio Hanson had one tackle, a tackle for a loss on Roy E. Williams, a pass defense, and a 96-yard fumble recovery for a touchdown, which Dawkins forced on Barber. Both Sean Considine and Asante Samuel had one tackle, and Sheldon Brown intercepted his first pass of the season, and his first in 19 games, and had three additional pass defenses. All toll, Dallas had 233 passing yards, but only 191 of them came from Romo and, later, Brooks Bollinger, as Witten had a 42-yard pass to Terrell Owens. Speaking of, Owens himself was the only consistent receiver, posting six receptions and 103 yards, while “Superstar” Williams had two receptions for four yards.
Unit Grade: A- (90%)
Special Teams: Every looked really good here, for a change. David Akers booted three field goals, and while he did miss one, it was way late when we were up 44-3 anyway, and he drilled a 50-yard field goal after special teams’ forced the fumble prior to the half on Adam “Pacman” Jones. Sav Rocca got back to more charted land as he punted three times (twice in the fourth quarter) and netted 41.3 a kick, thanks in large part to Jones being held to two yards a punt return on two tries. Together, the team of Jones and Miles Austin averaged only 20.4 yards a kick return and Jones fumbled one away prior to the half, with Demps on the hit and Gaither on the recovery. Jackson even got some breathing room on punts, averaging 12 yards a return on two tries, including 21-yard on one. But, I wish the same could be said for Demps on kick returns, as he averaged only 11 yards a return on two.
Coverage Grade: A+ (98%)
Akers Grade: A (95%)
Rocca Grade: A- (90%)
Coaching: First of all, I would like to say again that we committed not ONE penalty in this game, so the staff gets a huge spike in the grading scale for that. Defensively, the team did allow a few big pass plays here and there, but whatever it was that Dallas picked up, the defense turned it upside down with a fumble, or a sack, or an interception, so props for remedying those situations are in order. Special teams was nearly flawless, outside of weak kick return blocking and one meaningless missed field goal by Akers. But to be honest, I am shocked at the offense once again, as it seemed to take a decided 180 from last week when he went pass heavy. The team “ran” the ball 36 times, although only 31 should count, and we attempted 22 passes with the one time McNabb was sacked. And it’s not like only one back did all the work, because Westbrook and Buckhalter split the main handoffs 13-10. Finding a balance like this through the playoffs could see this team going further then anyone could possibly imagine.
Offensive Grade: A+ (98%)
Defensive Grade: A (95%)
Special Teams Grade: A- (90%)
Ripper’s Three Game Balls:
3. Joselio Hanson: Huge open field tackle on a much bigger receiver (Williams) and the longer of the two fumble recoveries for a touchdown
2. Brian Dawkins: Massive game again from the “Old Guy”: appears to be playing again like he did in December of 2006 when he was defensive player of the month.
1. Chris Clemons: In my opinion, played the best game of his career here: two sacks, a forced and recovered fumble, and a touchdown spelled domination.
Honorable Mention: Correll Buckhalter, Sheldon Brown, Darren Howard, Quintin Demps, and Donovan McNabb
Stats and Numbers of Interest:
-Since 2000, the Cowboys are 0-9 in season finales. This even includes the 2007 season, when they finished 13-3.
-Tony Romo is now 5-8 in the month of December, and 0-2 in the month of January.
-The Cowboys first field goal sustained 8:15 off the clock: that drive eclipsed the amount of time they held the ball in the final three quarters (4:06, 8:05, and 7:24).
-The nagging and complaining about the red zone offense seemed to find a resolution, as the team had three red zone attempts and made the end zone every time, and they even succeeded every time from “goal-to-go” yardage. In addition, the team managed to complete 50% of their third down tries (7-of-14).
-With his game today, DeSean Jackson led all rookies this season with 898 receiving yards, and also had 62 receptions as well.
-The difference of 38 points is the biggest margin of victory for either team since 1961, when the Eagles defeated the Cowboys 43-7 (36 points).
Well guys, I don’t know what was more fun…making the playoffs or trumping the Cowboys in order to get in. But, once again, had Houston and Oakland not won, then we wouldn’t be getting in, even with this game that we had. So I thank them two teams, and am looking forward to our wildcard match in the Metrodome next weekend, whenever it might occur.
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
Wednesday, December 24, 2008
Eagles Ve Redskins Game 2 Review
The situation was perfect for the Philadelphia Eagles: two AFC teams lent helping hands to gun down two of the Eagles’ main advisories in the wildcard race, as the Baltimore Ravens beat the Dallas Cowboys on Saturday Night 33-24, and then on Sunday afternoon, the San Diego Chargers beat the Buccaneers in Tampa Bay 41-24 to drop two teams closer to Philadelphia. And, going into the late afternoon game which was changed due to flex scheduling, all the Eagles had to do was get revenge on a team who had beaten them at home in week five. After all, the Eagles went to the Meadowlands and beat the Giants, so why not the Redskins in Fed-Ex?
And then, well, the offense turned Pre-Cardinals game again.
In a game that would have pushed the Eagles alone into the 6th spot in the NFC, the offense came out flat and stayed that way, save for one long pass on a field goal drive and the final drive of the game which came a yard short of the end zone with the clock running down from four seconds. The end result was a 10-3 Redskins victory and a season sweep of the Eagles by Washington. And realistically speaking, the Eagles can STILL make it in the playoffs, but the following things need to happen in week 17:
A) Eagles need to avenge a week two loss to the Cowboys with a victory at Lincoln Financial Field on Sunday.
B) In a revelation befitting to the “one team has nothing to play for and the other does” quota, the Oakland Raiders need to beat the Buccaneers in Tampa Bay, which would take them from well endowed in the playoffs at 9-3, to 9-7 on the season.
C) Then, the Eagles record of 9-6-1 would trump the matching 9-7 records possessed by Dallas and Tampa Bay.
But, somehow, I can’t see Oakland winning on the road, and I don’t think that Sundays in January will have any events for the team, unless it’s watching the game at home from the couch.
Quarterbacks: There were not a lot of things out of the realm of reality that could have went wrong in this game for Donovan McNabb, except for throwing an interception (which could have been the case at least three times). If he wasn’t throwing the ball behind receivers, he was throwing them to ones who were covered and getting killed, or receivers would drop passes. For the game, McNabb was 26 of 46 (56.2%) for 230 yards, no touchdowns, no interceptions, and a 70 QB rating. In addition, McNabb kept the ball and rolled out twice for eight yards and, on a sack, fumbled the ball for the game’s only turnover. I understand that the receiver drops were not his fault, but a lot of passes were being forced that either were incomplete or he was pitching them to targets who weren’t even remotely open by an inch.
McNabb Grade: C- (70%)
Running and Fullbacks: Remember when Andy Reid said that if we didn’t run for at least three yards a carry that he would abandon the run? Well, I’d hate to tell him this, but we averaged 3.9 rushing as a team and yet the ball was only taken 16 times and, of course, only 14 count because McNabb kept it twice on a rollout. Brian Westbrook was hobbled a little bit later on but took the ball 12 times for 45 yards and also caught six passes for 71 yards, including a 47-yard reception which led to our one and only field goal. DeSean Jackson had one rush for seven yards and had another which was negated by a holding call on Reggie Brown, and more disappointing was the one carry Correll Buckhalter got for two yards, while he had two receptions for 18 yards. And if it hadn’t been for one reception by Dan Klecko for two yards, I would have never known he was out there, same with Kyle Eckel.
Unit Grade: B (83%)
Wide Receivers: The loss of Kevin Curtis and Hank Baskett to injuries for this game is NO EXCUSE for a PATHETIC eight drops, six of them coming from this unit. Brown, who saw his first action in three weeks due to the injuries to the two mentioned out front, had four receptions for 47 yards, including the one at the goal line which ended the game, and contributed one drop. Both Jason Avant and Jackson had two receptions each, and while Avant had one drop on the game, NO ONE beat Jackson, who was credited with FOUR drops, including one where he beat DeAngelo Hall on the sideline and on the final drive in the end zone. And despite the injuries and receiver shortage, Greg Lewis had only one catch.
Unit Grade: D- (60%)
Tight Ends: Yes, LJ Smith DID lead the team with seven receptions, but he only averaged seven yards a catch, he dropped two passes, and completely missed on his blocking assignment on 3rd and goal at the 3, which forced us to go for the field goal. Brent Celek had one catch for eight yards and in my mind he could have been tagged with a drop but he didn’t get it.
Unit Grade: D- (60%)
Offensive line: The battle between Jon Runyan and Jason Taylor was often a struggle for Runyan, as Taylor had both of their sacks and the forced fumble along with a QB hurry. Tra Thomas held Andre Carter in check for the most part, although he still had two QB hurries. The line was not called for a penalty, but rarely was there a push up the middle for any runner who was lucky enough to get the ball. Still, aside from Taylor, the line did pretty well.
Unit Grade: B (85%)
Defensive line: Havoc was created by the defensive line, mostly by the defensive ends, and Jason Campbell could not step back without fear of getting smashed. Again arguably the best defensive player on the field, Trent Cole posted eight tackles to lead the line, along with a sack, a QB hurry, and a tackle for a loss. Mike Patterson had seven tackles on the game, all against the run and was a vital clog in the middle against Clinton Portis and Laddell Betts. Broderick Bunkley had four tackles along with a pass defense while rookie Trevor Laws had two tackles in the rotation behind Broderick and Mike. Victor Abiamiri had two tackles in the end rotation and also posted a sack, a tackle for a loss, and a forced fumble (which makes no sense because I remember Troy Aikman saying Campbell “Dropped the ball,” and he is NEVER wrong). Darren Howard had one tackle, two QB hurries, a pass defense, and a sack and would have had two if Chris Clemons, who had one tackle himself, wasn’t called for being “off sides.” Juqua Parker chipped in a pass defense as well, and Washington ran for 122 yards on 32 carries, although their 3.8 run per carry is awfully deferred by 14 yards a scramble for Campbell.
Unit Grade: A (95%)
Linebackers: The unit saw plenty of action against the run and in the form of passes out of the backfield and to the tight end. Stewart Bradley led the team with ten total tackles while Akeem Jordan had seven tackles and a tackle for a loss (three yards on Portis). Chris Gocong though was the busiest of the three all-around as he had six tackles, two pass defenses, and a tackle for a loss (two yards on Portis).
Unit Grade: A (93%)
Secondary: On 18 completed passes, Campbell only had 144 yards (127 after sacks) and no one receiver had a dominating effect in the game (Betts and Santana Moss had five receptions and 43 yards for Betts) but regardless the secondary still had two miscues. For one was Quintin Mikell who while he led the unit with six tackles and one QB hurry on a mad blitz, had a “pass defense” which should have been an “interception” in the end zone, leading to Washington’s 3-0 lead. Another was in the 4th quarter at 11:29 on a pass intended for Devin Thomas when Asante Samuel, who had four tackles for the game, dropped a sure handed interception, simply making THAT a pass defense. Brian Dawkins, attending his seventh pro bowl in February, had five tackles and a pass defense, while both Sheldon Brown and Joselio Hanson had three tackles each, and Quintin Demps had one on defense.
Unit Grade: B+ (89%)
Special Teams: Sub par overall, to be nice. David Akers made his one and only field kick, but Sav Rocca only averaged 39.8 a kick, and some sloppy punt coverage saw his net fall to 34.3 a kick on eight of them. Jackson had one punt return for seven yards and Demps had one kick return for 18 yards, while our coverage teams held Rock Cartwright to one kick return for 20 yards but Antwan Randle-El had 13.3 yards a punt return and a long of 36 yards. The X-factor was Ryan Plackemeier, who averaged 40 a punt and 34.1 net but put FIVE inside the 20-yard line.
Akers Grade: A (93%)
Rocca Grade: C+ (78%)
Coverage and Blocking Grade: D+ (68%)
Coaching: There is really nothing I can say about the defense, except for them two dropped interceptions. Special teams was not very good, especially covering punts and coverage for our own when we did get a shot. And, well, why am I not surprised that the old ways came back to life in this one? And by that I mean the totally titular play-calling again. All toll, we had 48 pass attempts including the two sacks, and 16 carries (again, if you count that McNabb scrambling was pass attempts, then 50-14). And I understand that passing might have been the best thing to do with Westbrook hobbled, but come on, we have TWO OTHER RUNNERS, and all the passes that were either missed, dropped, or nearly intercepted and we keep going at it. That is a poor job by the play caller, and I would be willing to bet 50 dollars that this imbalance means Andy is back on the signals again.
Unit Grade - Defense: A (95%)
Unit Grade - Special Teams: C (75%)
Unit Grade - Offense: D (65%)
Ripper’s Three Game Balls:
3. Chris Gocong: Very good game against run and pass.
2. Darren Howard: Should have had two sacks thanks to Clemons.
1. Trent Cole: Monster game again from a guy snubbed of the pro bowl.
Honorable Mention: Ryan Plackemeier (first Non-Eagle) and Victor Abiamiri
Stats and Numbers of Interest:
-Only two times did the Eagles manage to post net yard drives of 20 or more yards, 76 on a drive for the field goal, and 90 yards on the final drive which ended the game at the 1-yard line.
-Despite holding the ball for 33:14, nearly 1/3 of Washington’s time came in the 2nd quarter, when they held it for 11:12, managing only the field goal.
-Despite only scoring three points, the Eagles actually had more offense (275 to 249) but their 3rd down percentage collapsed again: where as over the last three wins they were 33 of 50 (60%) they were 3-of-14 in the game for 21%.
Well, even though every possible scenario exists for the Eagles to still make the playoffs, it becomes less likely if the offense that showed up in Landover comes home and shows up for the Cowboys. All this and NOW we have to hope that Oakland can beat Tampa Bay?
I think I will be going back to that “off-season thread” within the week with a full-on off-season landscape.
And then, well, the offense turned Pre-Cardinals game again.
In a game that would have pushed the Eagles alone into the 6th spot in the NFC, the offense came out flat and stayed that way, save for one long pass on a field goal drive and the final drive of the game which came a yard short of the end zone with the clock running down from four seconds. The end result was a 10-3 Redskins victory and a season sweep of the Eagles by Washington. And realistically speaking, the Eagles can STILL make it in the playoffs, but the following things need to happen in week 17:
A) Eagles need to avenge a week two loss to the Cowboys with a victory at Lincoln Financial Field on Sunday.
B) In a revelation befitting to the “one team has nothing to play for and the other does” quota, the Oakland Raiders need to beat the Buccaneers in Tampa Bay, which would take them from well endowed in the playoffs at 9-3, to 9-7 on the season.
C) Then, the Eagles record of 9-6-1 would trump the matching 9-7 records possessed by Dallas and Tampa Bay.
But, somehow, I can’t see Oakland winning on the road, and I don’t think that Sundays in January will have any events for the team, unless it’s watching the game at home from the couch.
Quarterbacks: There were not a lot of things out of the realm of reality that could have went wrong in this game for Donovan McNabb, except for throwing an interception (which could have been the case at least three times). If he wasn’t throwing the ball behind receivers, he was throwing them to ones who were covered and getting killed, or receivers would drop passes. For the game, McNabb was 26 of 46 (56.2%) for 230 yards, no touchdowns, no interceptions, and a 70 QB rating. In addition, McNabb kept the ball and rolled out twice for eight yards and, on a sack, fumbled the ball for the game’s only turnover. I understand that the receiver drops were not his fault, but a lot of passes were being forced that either were incomplete or he was pitching them to targets who weren’t even remotely open by an inch.
McNabb Grade: C- (70%)
Running and Fullbacks: Remember when Andy Reid said that if we didn’t run for at least three yards a carry that he would abandon the run? Well, I’d hate to tell him this, but we averaged 3.9 rushing as a team and yet the ball was only taken 16 times and, of course, only 14 count because McNabb kept it twice on a rollout. Brian Westbrook was hobbled a little bit later on but took the ball 12 times for 45 yards and also caught six passes for 71 yards, including a 47-yard reception which led to our one and only field goal. DeSean Jackson had one rush for seven yards and had another which was negated by a holding call on Reggie Brown, and more disappointing was the one carry Correll Buckhalter got for two yards, while he had two receptions for 18 yards. And if it hadn’t been for one reception by Dan Klecko for two yards, I would have never known he was out there, same with Kyle Eckel.
Unit Grade: B (83%)
Wide Receivers: The loss of Kevin Curtis and Hank Baskett to injuries for this game is NO EXCUSE for a PATHETIC eight drops, six of them coming from this unit. Brown, who saw his first action in three weeks due to the injuries to the two mentioned out front, had four receptions for 47 yards, including the one at the goal line which ended the game, and contributed one drop. Both Jason Avant and Jackson had two receptions each, and while Avant had one drop on the game, NO ONE beat Jackson, who was credited with FOUR drops, including one where he beat DeAngelo Hall on the sideline and on the final drive in the end zone. And despite the injuries and receiver shortage, Greg Lewis had only one catch.
Unit Grade: D- (60%)
Tight Ends: Yes, LJ Smith DID lead the team with seven receptions, but he only averaged seven yards a catch, he dropped two passes, and completely missed on his blocking assignment on 3rd and goal at the 3, which forced us to go for the field goal. Brent Celek had one catch for eight yards and in my mind he could have been tagged with a drop but he didn’t get it.
Unit Grade: D- (60%)
Offensive line: The battle between Jon Runyan and Jason Taylor was often a struggle for Runyan, as Taylor had both of their sacks and the forced fumble along with a QB hurry. Tra Thomas held Andre Carter in check for the most part, although he still had two QB hurries. The line was not called for a penalty, but rarely was there a push up the middle for any runner who was lucky enough to get the ball. Still, aside from Taylor, the line did pretty well.
Unit Grade: B (85%)
Defensive line: Havoc was created by the defensive line, mostly by the defensive ends, and Jason Campbell could not step back without fear of getting smashed. Again arguably the best defensive player on the field, Trent Cole posted eight tackles to lead the line, along with a sack, a QB hurry, and a tackle for a loss. Mike Patterson had seven tackles on the game, all against the run and was a vital clog in the middle against Clinton Portis and Laddell Betts. Broderick Bunkley had four tackles along with a pass defense while rookie Trevor Laws had two tackles in the rotation behind Broderick and Mike. Victor Abiamiri had two tackles in the end rotation and also posted a sack, a tackle for a loss, and a forced fumble (which makes no sense because I remember Troy Aikman saying Campbell “Dropped the ball,” and he is NEVER wrong). Darren Howard had one tackle, two QB hurries, a pass defense, and a sack and would have had two if Chris Clemons, who had one tackle himself, wasn’t called for being “off sides.” Juqua Parker chipped in a pass defense as well, and Washington ran for 122 yards on 32 carries, although their 3.8 run per carry is awfully deferred by 14 yards a scramble for Campbell.
Unit Grade: A (95%)
Linebackers: The unit saw plenty of action against the run and in the form of passes out of the backfield and to the tight end. Stewart Bradley led the team with ten total tackles while Akeem Jordan had seven tackles and a tackle for a loss (three yards on Portis). Chris Gocong though was the busiest of the three all-around as he had six tackles, two pass defenses, and a tackle for a loss (two yards on Portis).
Unit Grade: A (93%)
Secondary: On 18 completed passes, Campbell only had 144 yards (127 after sacks) and no one receiver had a dominating effect in the game (Betts and Santana Moss had five receptions and 43 yards for Betts) but regardless the secondary still had two miscues. For one was Quintin Mikell who while he led the unit with six tackles and one QB hurry on a mad blitz, had a “pass defense” which should have been an “interception” in the end zone, leading to Washington’s 3-0 lead. Another was in the 4th quarter at 11:29 on a pass intended for Devin Thomas when Asante Samuel, who had four tackles for the game, dropped a sure handed interception, simply making THAT a pass defense. Brian Dawkins, attending his seventh pro bowl in February, had five tackles and a pass defense, while both Sheldon Brown and Joselio Hanson had three tackles each, and Quintin Demps had one on defense.
Unit Grade: B+ (89%)
Special Teams: Sub par overall, to be nice. David Akers made his one and only field kick, but Sav Rocca only averaged 39.8 a kick, and some sloppy punt coverage saw his net fall to 34.3 a kick on eight of them. Jackson had one punt return for seven yards and Demps had one kick return for 18 yards, while our coverage teams held Rock Cartwright to one kick return for 20 yards but Antwan Randle-El had 13.3 yards a punt return and a long of 36 yards. The X-factor was Ryan Plackemeier, who averaged 40 a punt and 34.1 net but put FIVE inside the 20-yard line.
Akers Grade: A (93%)
Rocca Grade: C+ (78%)
Coverage and Blocking Grade: D+ (68%)
Coaching: There is really nothing I can say about the defense, except for them two dropped interceptions. Special teams was not very good, especially covering punts and coverage for our own when we did get a shot. And, well, why am I not surprised that the old ways came back to life in this one? And by that I mean the totally titular play-calling again. All toll, we had 48 pass attempts including the two sacks, and 16 carries (again, if you count that McNabb scrambling was pass attempts, then 50-14). And I understand that passing might have been the best thing to do with Westbrook hobbled, but come on, we have TWO OTHER RUNNERS, and all the passes that were either missed, dropped, or nearly intercepted and we keep going at it. That is a poor job by the play caller, and I would be willing to bet 50 dollars that this imbalance means Andy is back on the signals again.
Unit Grade - Defense: A (95%)
Unit Grade - Special Teams: C (75%)
Unit Grade - Offense: D (65%)
Ripper’s Three Game Balls:
3. Chris Gocong: Very good game against run and pass.
2. Darren Howard: Should have had two sacks thanks to Clemons.
1. Trent Cole: Monster game again from a guy snubbed of the pro bowl.
Honorable Mention: Ryan Plackemeier (first Non-Eagle) and Victor Abiamiri
Stats and Numbers of Interest:
-Only two times did the Eagles manage to post net yard drives of 20 or more yards, 76 on a drive for the field goal, and 90 yards on the final drive which ended the game at the 1-yard line.
-Despite holding the ball for 33:14, nearly 1/3 of Washington’s time came in the 2nd quarter, when they held it for 11:12, managing only the field goal.
-Despite only scoring three points, the Eagles actually had more offense (275 to 249) but their 3rd down percentage collapsed again: where as over the last three wins they were 33 of 50 (60%) they were 3-of-14 in the game for 21%.
Well, even though every possible scenario exists for the Eagles to still make the playoffs, it becomes less likely if the offense that showed up in Landover comes home and shows up for the Cowboys. All this and NOW we have to hope that Oakland can beat Tampa Bay?
I think I will be going back to that “off-season thread” within the week with a full-on off-season landscape.
Wednesday, December 17, 2008
Eagles Vs Browns Review
On primetime games, the Philadelphia Eagles have not faired too well, going back to the end of the 2006 season. They lost every game they played in the spotlight in 2007, and had lost every game leading up to Thanksgiving this year when they played the Arizona Cardinals. So, against a team that had a 2-0 record on Monday Night, having defeated the New York Giants and the Buffalo Bills on ESPN, you would think there would be some level of concern. And you also must factor in that the opposing team, the Cleveland Browns, were 4-9 and had nothing to fight for anymore, having been eliminated from playoff contention for at least two weeks.
Oh wait I’m sorry, we were playing the BROWNS…silly me!
Clearly a franchise in turmoil from the ground up, the Browns played like it as the Eagles kept the picture on the playoffs sharpened with a 30-10 victory in the Monday Night Main Event. And you must consider two more things before looking at that final score and thinking that is impressive as is:
A) The Eagles squandered two very good red zone opportunities to score touchdowns and if they had hit, the score would have been 44-10.
B) The Browns only touchdown of the game came with nine minutes left in the game, due to Kevin Kolb being picked off by Brandon McDonald. Combining the scenarios from A and B, the score SHOULD have been 44-3.
As is, the victory makes the Eagles 8-5-1 but does nothing for their playoff positioning, because Atlanta and Dallas both won on Sunday, and with the Falcons beating the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, that now makes three teams who possess 9-5 records, a half game ahead of the Eagles. The only redeeming quality about the weekend were losses by the New Orleans Saints and the Washington Redskins eliminated the former team, and the latter might as well be eliminated.
Quarterbacks: As I had figured, we would see more of Donovan McNabb throwing the ball, and while his attempts went up from seven the week before, it was the deadly accuracy and that laser pass he displayed that wrecked the already crappy Browns secondary. In conditions overcast and then turning to rain, McNabb hit 26 of 35 passes (74.3%) for 290 yards, two touchdowns, and an interception. And in his defense, while the pass was a little under where Hank Baskett should have been, an argument for McDonald getting the interception could have been Baskett gave up on it. But it was his only bad pass, which is FAR more then we can say about anyone else who “tried” to throw the ball. Kolb, who appeared for the last ten minutes of the game when we WERE up 30-3, gift wrapped the Browns only touchdown to snap their long 240+ minute touchdown-less drought, and was 0-for-2 with the interception. And in a well placed call but poorly executed throw, DeSean Jackson tried to throw the ball from the Wildcat, but was picked off by Sean Jones.
Donovan Grade: A (93%)
Any other “Thrower’s Grade: F (50%)
Running Backs & Fullbacks: In the Giants win, Brian Westbrook had 31 carries by himself. And in this game, we ran the ball 31 times again, but this time you would be hard pressed to find out that it wasn’t ALL Westbrook this time around. Correll Buckhalter, who missed the last two games due to a knee injury suffered in Baltimore, led the team with 55 yards on six carries, including a 27-yard run which set up the last touchdown we scored off of Ken Dorsey’s second interception. Westbrook had 16 carries for 53 yards and also three receptions for 14 yards, and Kyle Eckel, seeing all of his work running when Kolb joined the game, had nine carries for 28 yards, averaging barely three yards a carry. Dan Klecko had one catch for six yards, and a few impressive truck blocks.
Unit Grade: B+ (88%)
Wide Receivers: Every game there is someone new who creates an ethic mismatch for the defense (after all, pass distribution, which has been our offensive trademark, will do that for you) and this game it was the Jason Avant show. Avant co-led the team with five receptions and posted 101 yards, including a David Blaine approved magic trick where he was locked up with Cornerback Eric Wright and still made the catch. Jackson had five receptions as well for 77 yards, and Kevin Curtis had four receptions for 45 yards, also beating Wright, only this time cleanly in 1-on-1 coverage in the end zone. Hank Baskett had three receptions for 15 yards but 14 on one catch, while we had a Greg Lewis sighting, none the less in the end zone as he caught one there from 10-yards out.
Unit Grade: A- (90%)
Tight Ends: If it hadn’t been for run blocking, I would have forgotten LJ Smith and Brent Celek were even there. Both of them had two receptions, Celek had the first one of the game for a yard, and Smith caught one for 11 yards.
Unit Grade: B (85%)
Offensive Line: It is understandable that interior lines are going to struggle against Shaun “Big Baby” Rogers, but the fact that Rogers only had three tackles and a pass defense should bring some recognition to the interior three, more so Jamaal Jackson and Nick Cole. The Browns did get two sacks from linebackers Willie McGinest and Kameron Wimbley, but that is as much McNabb’s fault for dancing as it is the ethic mismatch the 3-4 defense presents. And the Eagles’ only penalty of the game was on Tra Thomas for getting a head start on the play. By the way, did you notice that not only did Mike McGlynn get in for I believe was Tra, but they were actually playing Winston Justice at right tackle for Jon Runyan?
Unit Grade: A- (90%)
Oh wait I’m sorry, we were playing the BROWNS…silly me!
Clearly a franchise in turmoil from the ground up, the Browns played like it as the Eagles kept the picture on the playoffs sharpened with a 30-10 victory in the Monday Night Main Event. And you must consider two more things before looking at that final score and thinking that is impressive as is:
A) The Eagles squandered two very good red zone opportunities to score touchdowns and if they had hit, the score would have been 44-10.
B) The Browns only touchdown of the game came with nine minutes left in the game, due to Kevin Kolb being picked off by Brandon McDonald. Combining the scenarios from A and B, the score SHOULD have been 44-3.
As is, the victory makes the Eagles 8-5-1 but does nothing for their playoff positioning, because Atlanta and Dallas both won on Sunday, and with the Falcons beating the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, that now makes three teams who possess 9-5 records, a half game ahead of the Eagles. The only redeeming quality about the weekend were losses by the New Orleans Saints and the Washington Redskins eliminated the former team, and the latter might as well be eliminated.
Quarterbacks: As I had figured, we would see more of Donovan McNabb throwing the ball, and while his attempts went up from seven the week before, it was the deadly accuracy and that laser pass he displayed that wrecked the already crappy Browns secondary. In conditions overcast and then turning to rain, McNabb hit 26 of 35 passes (74.3%) for 290 yards, two touchdowns, and an interception. And in his defense, while the pass was a little under where Hank Baskett should have been, an argument for McDonald getting the interception could have been Baskett gave up on it. But it was his only bad pass, which is FAR more then we can say about anyone else who “tried” to throw the ball. Kolb, who appeared for the last ten minutes of the game when we WERE up 30-3, gift wrapped the Browns only touchdown to snap their long 240+ minute touchdown-less drought, and was 0-for-2 with the interception. And in a well placed call but poorly executed throw, DeSean Jackson tried to throw the ball from the Wildcat, but was picked off by Sean Jones.
Donovan Grade: A (93%)
Any other “Thrower’s Grade: F (50%)
Running Backs & Fullbacks: In the Giants win, Brian Westbrook had 31 carries by himself. And in this game, we ran the ball 31 times again, but this time you would be hard pressed to find out that it wasn’t ALL Westbrook this time around. Correll Buckhalter, who missed the last two games due to a knee injury suffered in Baltimore, led the team with 55 yards on six carries, including a 27-yard run which set up the last touchdown we scored off of Ken Dorsey’s second interception. Westbrook had 16 carries for 53 yards and also three receptions for 14 yards, and Kyle Eckel, seeing all of his work running when Kolb joined the game, had nine carries for 28 yards, averaging barely three yards a carry. Dan Klecko had one catch for six yards, and a few impressive truck blocks.
Unit Grade: B+ (88%)
Wide Receivers: Every game there is someone new who creates an ethic mismatch for the defense (after all, pass distribution, which has been our offensive trademark, will do that for you) and this game it was the Jason Avant show. Avant co-led the team with five receptions and posted 101 yards, including a David Blaine approved magic trick where he was locked up with Cornerback Eric Wright and still made the catch. Jackson had five receptions as well for 77 yards, and Kevin Curtis had four receptions for 45 yards, also beating Wright, only this time cleanly in 1-on-1 coverage in the end zone. Hank Baskett had three receptions for 15 yards but 14 on one catch, while we had a Greg Lewis sighting, none the less in the end zone as he caught one there from 10-yards out.
Unit Grade: A- (90%)
Tight Ends: If it hadn’t been for run blocking, I would have forgotten LJ Smith and Brent Celek were even there. Both of them had two receptions, Celek had the first one of the game for a yard, and Smith caught one for 11 yards.
Unit Grade: B (85%)
Offensive Line: It is understandable that interior lines are going to struggle against Shaun “Big Baby” Rogers, but the fact that Rogers only had three tackles and a pass defense should bring some recognition to the interior three, more so Jamaal Jackson and Nick Cole. The Browns did get two sacks from linebackers Willie McGinest and Kameron Wimbley, but that is as much McNabb’s fault for dancing as it is the ethic mismatch the 3-4 defense presents. And the Eagles’ only penalty of the game was on Tra Thomas for getting a head start on the play. By the way, did you notice that not only did Mike McGlynn get in for I believe was Tra, but they were actually playing Winston Justice at right tackle for Jon Runyan?
Unit Grade: A- (90%)
Defensive Line: Despite only punching out one sack up front, it appeared as if Trent Cole was paying way more visits to Dorsey then he would have liked. Cole led the front line with four tackles, three QB hurries, and the lone sack while Juqua Parker and Broderick Bunkley had two tackles each, the former with one hurry as well. Trevor Laws and Victor Abiamiri each had one tackle each, while Darren Howard and Chris Clemons, without a tackle, were still around the ball. Oh, and here is one for you: the “Great” Jamal Lewis had 32 yards rushing and the team had 57 total.
Unit Grade: B (85%)
Linebackers: While the Browns employ four linebackers (Wimbley, McGinest, Andra Davis, and D’Qwell Jackson) not one of them was as good as Stewart Bradley was. Bradley led the team with six tackles, three of them for a loss including a hit on Lewis where he went right through Ex-Eagle center Hank Fraley and one where he blew up Josh Cribbs on a running play, and an interception with Dorsey treating him like a Browns tight end. Akeem Jordan had five tackles while Chris Gocong had three tackles but is more revered for his penalty which was not when he shoved Jason Wright down as he was leaving the backfield.
Unit Grade: A- (90%)
Secondary: Braylon Edwards was an ethic mismatch for whoever he was up against, and Darnell Dinkins dropped a pass as he was wide open, which could have made the game 7-7 early on. But other then that, pass coverage was pretty much air tight, leaving Dorsey to only 156 yards passing and 139 after two sacks. Sheldon Brown led the secondary with five tackles while Brian Dawkins had four, including taking a page from Stewart’s book and blowing up Cribbs on a wildcat run. Quintin Demps, Quintin Mikell, and Asante Samuel had one tackle each, Demps had a sack late in the game when subbed in, Samuel had an interception for a touchdown, his first as an Eagle, and both Brown and Joselio Hanson dropped sure interceptions. But the big question is, what happened to Lito Sheppard? Did someone forget to tell him there was a game or what?
Unit Rating: A (93%)
Special Teams: Well, seeing no blocked field goals was a good thing, as David Akers hit all three field goals and all three extra points for 12 total, while Sav Rocca was only needed to punt twice, both times in the 4th quarter, putting one inside the 20. Demps had three kick returns and averaged 29 yards a return, including a 39-yard return on the second drive, while fancy man Jackson averaged one yard on three punt returns. Coverage, meanwhile, held the dangerous Cribbs to 21 yards a kick return, and kept him with no punt returns as well.
Coverage grade: A+ (98%)
Akers and returns grade: A- (90%)
Rocca Grade: B- (80%)
Coaching: Plenty of blitzes were brought, and while they only got to Ken twice, it was pretty obvious he was rattled by it. Special teams was very good all around, except for a shank punt by Rocca on the second kick in the final quarter. On offense, we attempted 40 passes (although 37 of them were from McNabb, three from other “good” sources) and we ran the ball 31 times. But I can see why the pass was called a little bit more, because a lot of them were beating the Browns every which way but straight. I am just surprised that Buckhalter actually got six carries in his first game back in three weeks.
Coaching Grade: A (93%)
Ripper’s Three Game Balls:
3. Stewart Bradley: Led defense in tackles and was wide open on his interception.
2. Asante Samuel: First touchdown as an Eagle came after Jackson was picked off in the end zone to negate his mistake.
1. Donovan McNabb: Aerodynamic and laser like passes too much for the Browns: made only one mistake before the half with pick.
Honorable Mentions: Jason Avant and Trent Cole
Numbers and Stats of Interest:
-Two of our most beloved veterans reached game milestones by starting on Monday Night: Dawkins bypassed Harold Carmichael on the all-time list for most games played as an Eagle with 181 games. Also, Runyan played in his 200th career game between Philadelphia and Tennessee, and started his 190th straight game.
-For the third straight game, the Eagles completed over 60% of their third down conversions, hitting 11-of-17 for 64%. Also, the Eagles held the ball for over 35 minutes for the third straight game, posting up 37:08 in T.O.P.
-But, once again, the red zone offense was horrible. The team was 2-of-7 (28%) in the red zone, settling for three field goals and were picked off twice. Worse yet was the goal-to-goal situations, going 1-of-4 for 25%.
The Eagles took care of business by beating down a team that had nothing left to lose, being 4-9 previously. But the next two games are pivotal for the Eagles, and getting a helping hand in only one mere loss by either Atlanta or Tampa Bay will leave the sixth spot wide open with their names on it. If the Eagles can play the game that has won them three straight contests, then getting revenge for early seasons losses to the Redskins and Cowboys will be eminent.
Unit Grade: B (85%)
Linebackers: While the Browns employ four linebackers (Wimbley, McGinest, Andra Davis, and D’Qwell Jackson) not one of them was as good as Stewart Bradley was. Bradley led the team with six tackles, three of them for a loss including a hit on Lewis where he went right through Ex-Eagle center Hank Fraley and one where he blew up Josh Cribbs on a running play, and an interception with Dorsey treating him like a Browns tight end. Akeem Jordan had five tackles while Chris Gocong had three tackles but is more revered for his penalty which was not when he shoved Jason Wright down as he was leaving the backfield.
Unit Grade: A- (90%)
Secondary: Braylon Edwards was an ethic mismatch for whoever he was up against, and Darnell Dinkins dropped a pass as he was wide open, which could have made the game 7-7 early on. But other then that, pass coverage was pretty much air tight, leaving Dorsey to only 156 yards passing and 139 after two sacks. Sheldon Brown led the secondary with five tackles while Brian Dawkins had four, including taking a page from Stewart’s book and blowing up Cribbs on a wildcat run. Quintin Demps, Quintin Mikell, and Asante Samuel had one tackle each, Demps had a sack late in the game when subbed in, Samuel had an interception for a touchdown, his first as an Eagle, and both Brown and Joselio Hanson dropped sure interceptions. But the big question is, what happened to Lito Sheppard? Did someone forget to tell him there was a game or what?
Unit Rating: A (93%)
Special Teams: Well, seeing no blocked field goals was a good thing, as David Akers hit all three field goals and all three extra points for 12 total, while Sav Rocca was only needed to punt twice, both times in the 4th quarter, putting one inside the 20. Demps had three kick returns and averaged 29 yards a return, including a 39-yard return on the second drive, while fancy man Jackson averaged one yard on three punt returns. Coverage, meanwhile, held the dangerous Cribbs to 21 yards a kick return, and kept him with no punt returns as well.
Coverage grade: A+ (98%)
Akers and returns grade: A- (90%)
Rocca Grade: B- (80%)
Coaching: Plenty of blitzes were brought, and while they only got to Ken twice, it was pretty obvious he was rattled by it. Special teams was very good all around, except for a shank punt by Rocca on the second kick in the final quarter. On offense, we attempted 40 passes (although 37 of them were from McNabb, three from other “good” sources) and we ran the ball 31 times. But I can see why the pass was called a little bit more, because a lot of them were beating the Browns every which way but straight. I am just surprised that Buckhalter actually got six carries in his first game back in three weeks.
Coaching Grade: A (93%)
Ripper’s Three Game Balls:
3. Stewart Bradley: Led defense in tackles and was wide open on his interception.
2. Asante Samuel: First touchdown as an Eagle came after Jackson was picked off in the end zone to negate his mistake.
1. Donovan McNabb: Aerodynamic and laser like passes too much for the Browns: made only one mistake before the half with pick.
Honorable Mentions: Jason Avant and Trent Cole
Numbers and Stats of Interest:
-Two of our most beloved veterans reached game milestones by starting on Monday Night: Dawkins bypassed Harold Carmichael on the all-time list for most games played as an Eagle with 181 games. Also, Runyan played in his 200th career game between Philadelphia and Tennessee, and started his 190th straight game.
-For the third straight game, the Eagles completed over 60% of their third down conversions, hitting 11-of-17 for 64%. Also, the Eagles held the ball for over 35 minutes for the third straight game, posting up 37:08 in T.O.P.
-But, once again, the red zone offense was horrible. The team was 2-of-7 (28%) in the red zone, settling for three field goals and were picked off twice. Worse yet was the goal-to-goal situations, going 1-of-4 for 25%.
The Eagles took care of business by beating down a team that had nothing left to lose, being 4-9 previously. But the next two games are pivotal for the Eagles, and getting a helping hand in only one mere loss by either Atlanta or Tampa Bay will leave the sixth spot wide open with their names on it. If the Eagles can play the game that has won them three straight contests, then getting revenge for early seasons losses to the Redskins and Cowboys will be eminent.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
