Eagles Vs Giants Review

RipperEagle Retrospectives:
Week 10: Giants @ Eagles
By RipperEagle (RE96)

As expected when it comes down to many of the battles between the Eagles and their NFC East brethren, the games are always going to be exciting, close in score, and feature things you aren’t going to find in other matches out there. And Sunday Night’s game with the visiting Giants was no exception to this rule: guys who weigh 264 pounds flying through the air, a defensive tackle picking off a pass and rumbling with it, and two silly challenges in a row by one coach and a challenge on another call which was unjust by the other. But the bottom line is that, right in front of the Eagles was their chance at their very first division win, and the opportunity to knock off the defending Superbowl Champions.

But like with our other primetime games, this didn’t happen.

The score went one way from the next: the Eagles had a 7-0 lead right away, then the Giants led 17-7, then the Eagles led 24-20, then the Giants led 36-24. But when all was said and done, the Giants defeated the Eagles 36-31 thanks to some silly play calling on 3rd and 3 and 4th and 1 to end part of the game on.

Quarterbacks: As has been the case with the past two weeks, Donovan McNabb got off to yet another slow, ice cold start. But unlike other units and players, he once again found his bearings to a degree once more this time as he hit 17 of 36 passes (47%) for 194 yards, three touchdowns, and an interception. And he also led the team with 35 yards rushing on three carries. Thanks to the offensive line, McNabb had plenty of time to throw the ball, but a lot of the misses came as a result of forcing to someone who wasn’t open, or again, drops.
McNabb Grade: B- (80%)

Running & Full Backs: What a sad showing from the actual runners. The reason I say actual runners is because a receiver (DeSean Jackson) had more rushing yards then the backup runner and also two less then the starter. Brian Westbrook carried the ball 13 times for 26 yards and caught three passes for 33 yards, clearly a non-factor. Correll Buckhalter had two carries for 21 yards, but 20 of them were on one run. Dan Klecko, more then not, missed a good amount of lead blocks, and I got to wonder, where DID Kyle Eckel go, Antarctica?
Unit Grade: C (75%)

Receivers: Jackson was the team’s best receiver and third best runner: he had four receptions for 61 yards and ran the ball three times for 24 yards and a 10-yard touchdown run from the wildcat formation. Two receivers tallied 25 yard receiving and a touchdown with Kevin Curtis getting there on three catches, and Jason Avant on two receptions while both Hank Baskett and Reggie Brown had a seven yard reception, Hank using his size in the end zone to post the third touchdown.
Jackson Grade: A (95%)
Unit Grade: B- (80%)

Tight Ends: What a difference a week makes: last week, Brent Celek was a superstar, and this week, he had one notable lazy drop but nothing else. Instead, it was the returning LJ Smith who finished second with three receptions for 36 yards. Obviously, the Giants defense is much better then the Seahawks defense, so now the question is, was that a fluke or not?
Unit Grade: C (75%)

Offensive Line: No one can blame the big guys for not doing their job. Up against the second best defense in terms of sacks and the best in the NFC, they allowed the Giants NO sacks and very few hurries or pressures either. And while the running game wasn’t too proficient with Brian or Correll running, only one time did someone get hit in the backfield for a 1-yard loss. Jon Runyan provided the block of the game on Jackson’s 10-yard touchdown run. And why Nick Cole started instead of Todd Herremans, who later came back, is a mystery to me.
Unit Grade: A+ (98%)

Defensive line: Save a sack, this unit was abysmal. They were easily engulfed by the Giants offensive line on the run, and more then not, were simply manhandled and pushed around in pass rushing. Broderick Bunkley had seven tackles even though he needed an IV for cramping later on while Trent Cole had six tackles and the game’s only sack. Juqua Parker posted four tackles, Trevor Laws had two tackles in extensive action for the missing Bunkley, and both Darren Howard and Mike Patterson had a tackle, although Patterson ALSO had his first interception and recovered a fumble by Brandon Jacobs. True, the defense got four tackles for a loss of 12 yards on the Giants, but 44 carries, 217 yards, and 4.9 yards a run loom larger then that minuscule stat.
Patterson Grade: A (93%)
Bunkley and Cole Grade: B (85%)
Unit Grade: C- (70%)

Linebackers: Often thrown into the fray when (insert name of Giants running back here) got past the first line of the defense, the linebackers had their hands full, some more so then others. Stewart Bradley posted a total of 14 tackles and also a facemask penalty while Chris Gocong had six tackles, one of which was a wicked shot on Jacobs which forced a fumble, and Omar Gaither had three tackles and a forced fumble which went out of bounds. Somehow, Akeem Jordon got in for a while at linebacker at someone’s expense and had two tackles as well.
Unit Grade: B (85%)

Secondary: Not a lot of activity here, although when you can run the ball like the Giants did, I guess I can understand why. Brian Dawkins had seven tackles and a forced fumble on the game while Joselio Hanson had four tackles and Asante Samuel had three. Quintin Mikell had three tackles but was best remembered for Kevin Boss hurdling right over him while Sean Considine had one tackle and Sheldon Brown had an assisted tackle. Not really tested that much except in the red zone with touchdowns by Boss and Burress.
Unit Grade: B- (80%)

Special Teams: David Akers and Sav Rocca both came to work again, Akers hitting four extra points and his only field goal try while Rocca punted five times with two inside the 20, a rare touchback, and a net average of 32.6, but only because of two Dominick Hixon punt returns for 22 yards an average. Jackson never got to return any of the three Giants punts, but Quintin Demps averaged 27 yards a kick return on eight of them and fumbled for the first time this season.
Akers and Rocca Grade: A- (90%)
Unit Grade: B- (80%)

Coaching: We have not been known as a running team, so I want to know who the genius was who thought that calling runs on 3rd and 3 and then 4th and 1 to a guy who was getting shut down was a good idea. Furthermore, Jimmy better chew out that pathetic run defense before we head to Cincinnati, and Rory needs to get the punt cover unit back to the tackling basics.
Unit Grade: C- (70%)

Ripper’s Three Game Balls:
3. Mike Patterson: First career INT and recovered fumble
2. DeSean Jackson: 85 yards of offense and a rushing touchdown
1. Offensive Line: Great job against the 3rd best defense in the NFL.

Numbers and Stats of Interest:
-Did you know that our record in primetime games, going back to 2007, is NOW at 0-7, and that includes an 0-5 mark against the NFC East?
-This is the second time this season we gave up more then 200 yards rushing in a game, the first time was again at home to Washington in week five.
-The Eagles held the ball for only 20:10 in the game.

I apologize for not having too much to say guys, but this loss really hurt. In my opinion, this is the WORST loss of the season just a bit ahead of losing to the Chicago Bears in week four.