Divisional Game: Eagles Beat Giants ..... Again

The situation and surroundings were ones that the teams were used to, on their own. Being on the road in the playoffs…the Eagles have done that before. Going to the Meadowlands…you bet they have done that before. But adding the two elements together under one hat provided for far more excitement then just that of any ole playoff game…this was a division rivalry match up in the playoffs! As it was during the season, the Eagles lost at home to the Giants, the defending Superbowl Champions from SB 42, but they got their revenge nearly a month later at the Giants’ house. But the question was, could lightning strike at the same stadium twice for the Eagles, this time looking to stamp their ticket for the NFC championship game? Would the Arizona Cardinals, who pulled off a stunning upset of the Carolina Panthers in Charlotte the night before 33-13, be going to New Jersey, or would their new stadium be hosting their first NFC title match?

Well, they did host the Superbowl last year, you know?

Despite being out gained on offense (the Giants had 307 yards to Philly’s 276) the defense harassed pro bowl quarterback Eli Manning into two of the team’s three turnovers and allowed not a single touchdown. In turn, the offense converted two red zone touchdowns from a yard out as they defeated the Giants for the second time this year on the road with a 23-11 victory. The victory puts the Eagles on the road against the equally as hot Cardinals in Glendale in a rematch of a Thanksgiving day hammering by the Eagles, 48-20. What is most strange about this match up is the seeding of the two teams: the Cardinals were #4 entering and the Eagles were #6, further proving that the season means nothing as the 12 combatants start over seemingly at 0-0.

Quarterbacks: Not much can be said about Donovan McNabb one way or the other. Up for debate would be the two interceptions (as to who’s fault the one to Kevin Dockery could be pinned on) but twice he was able to dig us out of 3rd and very long situations (15 and 20 yards). Even with the wind swirling around the Meadowlands and a few choice drops (see Kevin Curtis, sideline, 3rd quarter) McNabb was 22 of 40 (55%) for 217 yards with a passing touchdown and two interceptions for a 58 QB rating. But hey, it could always be worse right…I mean, just ask Eli Manning about that one. In addition, McNabb kept the ball five times for 16 yards, including a 1-yard QB sneak right up the gut for our first touchdown of the game. He also cost the team a safety with an intentional grounding call in the end zone, but that call, to me anyway, seemed just a bit “iffy.” And don’t forget, during the football off-season, if you need a directory assistant, switchboard operator, or a phone yes man, give ole Donny Mac a “ring” any time!
McNabb Grade: B- (81%)

Running Backs: Devoid of much fullback usage so we will go with this title today. Well, actually, we were devoid of much running either: including McNabb, who ran for 3.2 yards a scramble, the team ran 28 times for 59 yards, a measly 2.1 yards a carry. It’s pretty obvious that the running game has been keyed on, and blocking is not exactly what we have hoped for either, going hand in hand for a trip down “Catastrophe Circle.” Brian Westbrook was a non factor overall, running the ball 18 times for 36 yards and had two catches for only 10 yards. Receiving wise, Correll Buckhalter would fair somewhat better, posting three receptions for 19 yards but he would run five times for seven yards, including one run for six yards. Sightings of Dan Klecko were rarer then usual, except for when we scored in the red zone.
Unit Grade: C (75%)

Wide Receivers: Three receivers were featured and all three caught the passes, even though Reggie Brown and Hank Baskett were allegedly out there. DeSean Jackson, who oddly enough never got a receiver reverse, caught four passes for 81 yards, including a beautiful 48-yard grab down the sideline and short of a touchdown in the 4th quarter. Jason Avant was “Mister 3rd down” nearly reliving “4th and 26” with a 3rd down and 20 reception for 21 yards, totaling 43 yards on four grabs. Curtis, who had a brilliant pass right in his grasp only to drop it, had four catches for 40 yards. I rarely if ever saw Brown, and Baskett was rarely looked at. Also, Greg Lewis was deactivated for the game, allowing Victor Abiamiri to get back in.
Unit grade for those who caught passes: A (93%)

Tight Ends: Returning to the lineup was LJ Smith, but Brent Celek still would not repent. Celek had three receptions for only 12 yards, but one was a 1-yard floating touchdown reception. More over, Celek has improved his abilities has a chip blocker and a stand in blocker for running. Smith had two receptions for 12 yards in his first action this post season, missing the Vikings game for some reason or another. Smith was also flagged for a false start, the only one on offense all day.
Unit Grade: B (85%)

Offensive Line: At times, the offensive line struggled a good bit (see the six tackles for a loss, four QB hurries, whenever else they felt like running McNabb over) but at times they also seemed to be top notch (allowed no sacks, gave McNabb plenty of time to throw the ball on occasions). One flag was thrown for the unit, as Todd Herremans, who many Eagles fans felt could be on the pro bowl team or even an All-Pro left guard, was called for holding. But the tackles, Jon Runyan and Tra Thomas, did a great job against Mathias Kiwanuka (no tackles) and Justin Tuck (five tackles, but only one hurry). And keep in mind one thing: Runyan continues to play through a knee injury, and he was never exactly the most agile tackle to begin with. Overall, the effort was passable, but the middle three need to start getting a running push for whoever is carrying the ball.
Tackles Grade: A (95%)
Interior Grade: B- (80%)

Defensive line: Not only does Victor Abiamiri have a stand out name, but in his first playoff game as an Eagle, he made a stand out play as well. Abiamiri, who had three tackles for the game, picked up a fumble late to definitively ice the game after Steve Smith forgot how to turn and hold onto the ball in sequence. Key against the run were Trent Cole, who had six tackles and a pass defense, and Broderick Bunkley who had arguably his best game in a good while, posting five tackles but two very key tackles, with Mike Patterson on 4th and inches on a Manning sneak, and with Stewart Bradley on a 4th and two Brandon Jacobs run. Speaking of Big Mike, he had three tackles including his co-stop with his defensive tackle in crime, while Darren Howard had one tackle and a QB hurry. Both Chris Clemons and Juqua Parker had one tackle each as well, with Clemons adding a pass defense. Trevor Laws, getting in with the rotation at tackle, had one assist tackle. Despite Jacobs running for 92 yards on 19 carries, he had 24 yards on a run and rarely won a battle up the middle against Mike and Broderick, and Derrick Ward had 46 yards, but again, 14 of them on a single run.
Bunkley Grade: A+ (98%)
Unit Grade: A- (90%)

Linebackers: The question going into the game was, “Would Stewart Bradley be up to the task of stopping Jacobs and crew?” And while it was a give and take situation all day, Bradley more then won his fair share of battles, leading all defensive players (yes, including pudgy Antonio Pierce) with 11 tackles, playing clog in the middle and outside when he wasn’t getting knocked around by Madison Hedgecock. Chris Gocong, who keeps improving as the weeks go by against the run, posted eight tackles as well although five were in assist, and Akeem Jordan had one assist tackle on the game. Yeah, either the Giants were THAT worried about him, or he was THAT invisible and out of the picture, take your pick. Tank Daniels chipped in two tackles on special teams, while Omar Gaither and Tracey White had one each.
Bradley Grade: A (95%)
Gocong Grade: A- (90%)

Secondary: I don’t think there has been a game recently played by the Eagles that Brian Dawkins hasn’t been everywhere at once, and today you didn’t have to worry about him taking a vacation. Dawkins finished up second on the team with ten tackles and his safety partner in crime, Quintin Mikell, had a marvelous game. Mikell had six tackles, two pass defenses, an interception, and a tackle on special teams…oh, and he even missed a series in the 3rd quarter due to a knee issue. Asante Samuel AKA “Mr. Playoffs” managed to keep that moniker alive with four tackles and another interception this week, although he didn’t find the house (he did find the 2-yard line though) and a pass defense as well…oh, and no football where his crotch should be either! Both Joselio Hanson and Quintin Demps had two tackles on defense and one on special teams but Hanson was guilty on the one BIG play the Giants did manage passing to Dominick Hixon for 34-yards. Sheldon Brown had one tackle, and Sean Considine, who played for Mikell when he was in the locker room, had one pass defense, a teams tackle, and one dumb blocking penalty on punt returns. As a direct result of the pass rush even without a sack, Manning only mustered 169 passing yards and didn’t even come close to a touchdown pass, making life for the secondary that much easier.
Samuel & Mikell Grade: A+ (98%)
Dawkins Grade: A- (91%)
Others Grade: B (85%)

Special Teams: From the get go, David Akers knew he was going to get hands on and be ace all day. On the opening kick off, he kept Ahmad Bradshaw from scoring a touchdown by pushing him out at the Eagles 35, and he nailed three field goals and two extra points for 11 accounted points. Not bad for a guy who “struggled” at the Meadowlands (going in, he was 11-of-22 all time on field goal tries). Sav Rocca punted to a 42 yard average and 40 yard net, but was helped also not only by coverage, but the Giants taking three dumb penalties on punt returns, two in one sequence. Demps had a better day on kick returns unlike in Minnesota, averaging 27 yards a return on four tries and 46 for a long, starting off the 3rd quarter. Jackson didn’t get a punt return, but Jeff Feagles only had to punt twice, while Hixon had 2.7 yards a punt return on three, and Bradshaw had 30 yards a kick return, but 65 yards on the opening play of the game.
Akers Grade: A (95%)
Punt coverage grade: A- (90%)
Kick blocking and Rocca grade: B+ (88%)
Kick coverage grade: C+ (78%)

Coaching: There was certainly a lot of bending but no breaking by the defense, but they also managed three turnovers…all this while Jimmy Johnson was sitting up in the press box! Special teams, except for covering Bradshaw on kicks, looked solid overall otherwise. And a devotion to the running game, despite mediocre and less then desired results, needs to be kept. In a situation where it isn’t working, clearly passing the ball is the best way to go, but an offensive imbalance cannot be maintained, because we know what happens when things get lopsided.
Defense Grade: A (93%)
Special Teams Grade: B+ (88%)
Offense Grade: B- (80%)

Ripper’s Three Game Balls
3. Broderick Bunkley: If Avant is my slated “Mister 3rd down” on offense, then Bunkley is my “Mister 4th down” for the defense!
2. Asante Samuel: Now we know WHY we gave Samuel the money we gave him early: the guy makes plays in the PLAYOFFS!
1. Quintin Mikell: An incredible showing by arguably the most underrated defensive player on the team, outside the man in the #3 spot.
Honorable Mention: Stewart Bradley, DeSean Jackson, and David Akers

Stats and Numbers of Interest:
-With his three field goals on the game, Akers broke the playoff record for most consecutive field goals made. The previous record was 16, set by Morten Anderson: Akers now has made 18 in a row.
-With his interception in the first quarter, Samuel tied former teammate in New England Rodney Harrison for the lead amongst active players with seven interceptions in the playoffs.
-Including the playoffs and season, Dawkins has now played in his 200th game as a member of the Eagles.
-Despite taking an early 7-3 lead and then a 7-5 lead, the first four drives by the Eagles offense only managed to net minus four yards.
-This marks the 5th time in the past eight seasons that the Eagles will be going to the NFC title match, but only the second time they will be on the road.
-No playoff game has EVER ended with the score of 23-11...until now!
-As a general playoff note, three teams won over the weekend on the road. The thing they had in common…all three teams are named after birds. Baltimore won, Arizona, won, and then Philadelphia won.
-In addition, while both number one seeds in the AFC and NFC were eliminated (Tennessee and New York) both losing teams out gained the winning team on offense, but lost the turnover battle.

As the excitement and the anxiety stemming from the Giants victory comes to a head, take a moment to step back and look at the big picture which is now the NFC title game. How many people REALLY thought that, with teams like Carolina and New York being 12-4 and made out to be unstoppable and teams like Arizona and Philadelphia chastised for not being “worthy of the playoffs”, that the NFC title game would be between the Eagles and the Cardinals? And better yet…the game is in Glendale? Stay tuned, on “As the Pete Rozelle Smiles down at the lack of Parody in the NFL” continues in a weeks time!